Amidst Controversy: The Push to Protect Black History in Federal Agency Narratives

Altering the Narrative: Recent Developments

It seems the history books need a rewrite. In recent times, federal agencies have been caught in the crosshairs over allegations of erasing significant pieces of Black history, thanks to executive orders from the administration of President Donald Trump. The focus? Initiatives surrounding diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). What's at risk is our understanding of the vital roles played by figures like Harriet Tubman in the progression towards freedom.

In a surprising move, the National Park Service (NPS) altered its webpage dedicated to the Underground Railroad. This change downplayed Harriet Tubman’s significant contribution, even removing her photograph and thought-provoking quotes on enslavement. The public outcry was immense and, despite initial resistance, the NPS reversed its steps, returning the information to its rightful place.

The Larger Picture: More Than Just Edits

The Trump administration didn't stop there. In an executive order issued in March 2025, it turned its gaze towards the Smithsonian Institution, alleging it was spreading a “divisive, race-centered ideology.” Particular attention was on the National Museum of African American History and Culture. Vice President JD Vance was roped in to conduct an assessment and cut what was deemed improper ideology from Smithsonian programs. However, this inspection seemed too much for some, as the museum’s director, Kevin Young, resigned. Though sources insist his departure had no ties to the administration’s actions, skepticism remains.

The wave of erasures didn’t stop there. The Department of Defense saw temporary removals of content concerning Jackie Robinson’s service in the Army and information about Maj. Gen. Charles C. Rogers, a Medal of Honor recipient. As these narratives began disappearing, so did some landmarks. Black Lives Matter Plaza, a significant site established around the fervor following George Floyd’s tragic death in 2020, was first under threat of funding cuts and then slated for demolition.

On the ground, initiatives like the Descendants Project see the storm and aim to preserve what's left of African American history. Founders Jo and Joy Banner have set their sights on reviving historical sites in Louisiana. They are working to create museums and keep community stories alive for generations.

In another blow, historical designations have been revoked. An example is the 11-mile segment of the Great River Road in Louisiana, once recognized for its plantation ties. Despite acknowledgment of its historical value, this part has now lost its landmark status.

The concern among historians is palpable. Such acts risk painting a whitewashed picture of America's racially turbulent past, undermining efforts to acknowledge systemic racism. It’s a battle over narrative, with historians and advocates urging continued activism to ensure stories aren't rewritten, but preserved in their authentic form.